EV Myth: EVs merely shift emissions from roads to power stations

May 23, 2024

This common argument overlooks the significant strides made in transitioning to renewable energy sources for electricity generation, rendering it outdated and inaccurate.

As of March 2024, a substantial 67% of power supplied to the UK grid is sourced from zero-carbon sources. Wind power leads the pack at 49%, followed by gas at 15%, nuclear at 9%, and solar at 9%. The remaining portion consists of a mix of biomass, imports, and hydroelectric power. You can check the real-time UK power mix here

When driving an electric vehicle (EV) in the UK, particularly when charged on a low-carbon grid or during off-peak hours with renewable electricity, the emissions associated with charging the EV’s battery are minimal. Even in countries with coal-intensive grids, analysis by Carbon Brief indicates that an EV in China could offset its carbon debt at 22,000 miles and in Poland at 18,000 miles.

Furthermore, the latest report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reinforces the environmental benefits of EVs. The IPCC stated that “even with current grids, EVs reduce emissions in almost all cases.”

It’s crucial to recognise that electric cars are significantly more energy-efficient than combustion vehicles, approximately four times more so. Additionally, with around 80% of EV charging taking place at home during off-peak hours, often using low-cost electricity tariffs from providers offering certified renewable electricity, the claim that EV usage merely shifts pollution is factually incorrect.

In summary, EV adoption plays a vital role in reducing overall emissions, especially when coupled with the ongoing decarbonisation of electricity generation. This dispels the misconception that EVs merely relocate pollution from roads to power stations.